Magro’S Cincinnatus Menu

Magro’s Cincinnatus at 5758 Telephone Rd is a friendly neighborhood Italian pizzeria built around freshly baked pizza, hearty subs, sandwiches, calzones, wings, and classic shareable starters. Specialty pizzas add variety to the traditional cheese and meat-topped choices, with the Greek Spinach Pizza standing out for its combination of feta, vegetables, white sauce, and mozzarella. Cheese bread, breadsticks, garlic bread, and wings round out the casual menu, while cold soft drinks provide an easy pairing.

Magro’s is generally considered an affordable option, with large portions, generous toppings, and family-sized pizzas offering particularly good value. Recent diners praise the fresh-tasting dough and sauce, while melted mozzarella, seasoned meats, crisp vegetables, and golden baked crust create a satisfying balance of chewy, crisp, creamy, savory, and tangy flavors.

Vegetarian diners have several practical choices, especially the Greek Spinach Pizza and customizable vegetable pizzas. A dedicated gluten-free or vegan menu is not clearly published, so dietary requirements should be confirmed before ordering. The restaurant is kid-friendly, and simple cheese pizza, breadsticks, and mild subs work well for younger guests. Opening from late morning on most days, Magro’s suits lunch, dinner, takeaway, delivery, family meals, parties, and large group orders rather than breakfast.

Menu Highlights

Greek Spinach Pizza
Feta, red onion, tomato, mushrooms, spinach, white sauce, and mozzarella create a colorful vegetarian pizza. Creamy cheese and fresh vegetables make it one of the menu’s most distinctive published specialties.

Classic Pizza
Fresh-tasting dough and tomato sauce form the base for customizable cheese and topping combinations. Large slices and generous toppings have long made pizza the centerpiece of Magro’s menu.

Calzone
Baked dough surrounds a generous filling of cheese and selected toppings for a crisp exterior and rich, melty center. Customers have particularly praised Magro’s calzones for being packed with filling.

Chicken Wings
Wings provide a savory, shareable alternative to pizza and are sold in eight-piece portions. Their hearty character makes them a natural addition to family meals and group orders.

Cheese Bread
Bread is baked with melted cheese for a warm, chewy starter with lightly crisp edges. The simple combination makes it an easy crowd-pleaser before pizza or subs.

Breadsticks
Eight baked breadsticks offer a soft interior and golden exterior suited to dipping or sharing. Their mild flavor makes them especially approachable for families and children.

Garlic Bread
Warm bread is finished with savory garlic flavor for a classic Italian-American side. Its crisp edges and aromatic seasoning pair naturally with pizza, calzones, or sandwiches.