Magro’S Cincinnatus Magro’S Cincinnatus
  • Home
  • Menu
  • About
  • Photos
  • Reviews
  • Location
  • Magro’S Cincinnatus


    5758 Telephone Rd, Cincinnatus, NY 13040


  • Magro’S Cincinnatus


    +1 607-863-4434


Service options

+ Takeaway

+ Dine-in

Popular for

+ Lunch

+ Dinner

+ Solo dining

Accessibility

+ Wheelchair-accessible car park

+ Wheelchair-accessible seating

+ Wheelchair-accessible toilet

Offerings

+ Coffee

+ Comfort food

+ Quick bite

+ Small plates

Dining options

+ Lunch

+ Dinner

+ Seating

+ Table service

Amenities

+ Toilet

Atmosphere

+ Casual

+ Cosy

+ Quiet

Crowd

+ Groups

+ Tourists

Payments

+ Credit cards

+ Debit cards

+ NFC mobile payments

+ Credit cards

Children

+ Good for kids

+ High chairs

+ Kids' menu

Parking

+ Free of charge street parking

+ Free parking lot

+ Parking


Magro’S Cincinnatus menu

Pizza

$

Garlic Knots w Sauce

$

CocaCola Classic

$

Pizza Margherita

$

Taco Pizza

$

Pineapple N Pepperoni Pizza Slice

$

Pizza Made at Home

$

Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza

$

Full Menu

Discover Magro’S Cincinnatus

If you’re in the Cincinnatus area and looking for a place that serves hearty, delicious meals in a cozy atmosphere, look no further than Magro’s Cincinnatus. Situated at 5758 Telephone Rd, Cincinnatus, NY 13040, this diner is a local favorite, offering both comfort food and a friendly vibe that makes it stand out in the community.

The moment you step into Magro’s Cincinnatus, you’re greeted with a warm, inviting atmosphere. The layout of the restaurant makes it feel like a true diner, with booths and tables that cater to both small and large groups. The friendly staff immediately makes you feel at home, whether you’re a first-time visitor or a regular stopping by for your usual order.

What truly sets this spot apart, however, is the menu. Whether you’re in the mood for a quick bite or a full meal, you’ll find something to satisfy your cravings. From breakfast classics like fluffy pancakes and crispy bacon to hearty lunch and dinner options such as burgers, sandwiches, and fresh salads, the menu has something for everyone. Many regulars rave about the signature dishes, especially the home-style meatloaf and the chef’s daily specials. The portions are generous, so you definitely get value for your money.

One of the standout features of Magro’s Cincinnatus is its ability to cater to a wide range of tastes and dietary preferences. The restaurant offers gluten-free options, vegetarian dishes, and even a few vegan-friendly choices, ensuring there’s something for every guest. This thoughtful approach to menu variety has earned the restaurant praise for being inclusive while still maintaining the high quality of food that keeps people coming back.

In terms of experience, the diner has a great reputation for not just great food, but also excellent service. The staff are attentive without being overbearing, and they seem to genuinely care about making your dining experience enjoyable. On a recent visit, a server even took the time to offer suggestions for a first-time guest, which was a nice personal touch. That kind of service is rare but much appreciated and makes all the difference in elevating the dining experience.

If you’re considering a visit to Magro’s Cincinnatus, don’t miss out on the famous pies they bake daily. A warm slice of apple pie or a piece of creamy chocolate cream pie is the perfect way to end any meal. These desserts are a local favorite and frequently mentioned in reviews as a must-try.

Customer feedback often highlights the restaurant’s consistent quality and excellent prices. Diners appreciate that Magro’s Cincinnatus offers comfort food at affordable prices without compromising on taste. This combination of value and quality is one of the reasons why this diner is so popular with locals and travelers passing through Cincinnatus alike.

But it’s not just the food that makes this restaurant stand out. The welcoming environment and the sense of community it fosters are important aspects that many people keep coming back for. Whether it’s a casual meal with friends or a family gathering, the ambiance is relaxed, making it a great choice for any occasion.

What’s more, the diner is conveniently located at 5758 Telephone Rd, Cincinnatus, NY 13040, which makes it easy to find whether you’re in town for a day or have lived here for years. With its proximity to local attractions and its long-standing place in the community, it’s no wonder that Magro’s Cincinnatus continues to be a go-to spot for anyone looking for a satisfying meal in the area.

The restaurant’s reputation extends beyond just food and service. Over the years, it has built a loyal customer base, many of whom return for the familiar faces and comforting atmosphere. This sense of familiarity and trustworthiness has made Magro’s Cincinnatus a true gem in Cincinnatus, NY.

So, if you find yourself in the neighborhood, make sure to stop by for a bite at Magro’s Cincinnatus. With its great food, fantastic service, and homey vibe, it’s the kind of place that leaves you feeling satisfied and looking forward to your next visit.


Magro’S Cincinnatus Photos

Magro’S Cincinnatus Photo -1
Magro’S Cincinnatus Photo -2
Magro’S Cincinnatus Photo -3
Magro’S Cincinnatus Photo -4
Magro’S Cincinnatus Photo -5
Magro’S Cincinnatus Photo -6
Magro’S Cincinnatus Photo -7
Magro’S Cincinnatus Photo -8
Magro’S Cincinnatus Photo -9
Magro’S Cincinnatus Photo -10

Location & Contact

Get in touch with our support team


  • 5758 Telephone Rd, Cincinnatus, NY 13040
  • +1 607-863-4434




Clock


Hours

Our open schedules

Day
Monday Closed
Tuesday 10:30 AM - 09:00 PM
Wednesday 10:30 AM - 09:00 PM
Thursday 10:30 AM - 09:00 PM
Friday 10:30 AM - 10:00 PM
Saturday 10:30 AM - 10:00 PM
Sunday 02:00 PM - 09:00 PM



Reviews

  • Food is always good, convenient when not feeling like cooking, close to home and staff is always friendly!!

    Brittany Casterline
  • I love there pizza and wings they are my favorite and the service is good but sometimes they get ready buys and might take ur food a little bit longer to get done

    Kara Maclaury
  • Not as good as it once was but it may be that I'm just old and have been getting food there for 20+ years. I do like that they'll sell you dough to make it yourself witch is the best for us.

    Gary FRINK SR
  • Absolutely love eating here! They need to update the hours, online says closed certain days and on Facebook it says open. the food never fails, i’ve been eating here for 4 years now and it never disappoints!

    Sam Tsepelis
  • Loved this food for years quick and easy as well kid lives it aswell

    val yeaw
  • Awesome small town pizza shop. Highly recommend if you are passing through or down in the area.

    Keith Lowery

Explore More Taste

  • 95 Reviews

    Abc Mongolian Bbq

    Abc Mongolian Bbq

    Mongolian barbecue restaurant

    22415 Barton Rd, Grand Terrace, CA 92313

  • 364 Reviews

    Us-20 Diner

    Us-20 Diner

    Diner

    10938 US-20, Lyons, OH 43533

  • 658 Reviews

    Grillerz

    Grillerz

    Restaurant

    1070 County Rd 775 S, Nineveh, IN 46164

  • 2031 Reviews

    La Hacienda Mexican Restaurant

    La Hacienda Mexican Restaurant

    Mexican restaurant

    8086 N Davis Hwy, Pensacola, FL 32514

  • 785 Reviews

    Frazier's Dairy Maid

    Frazier's Dairy Maid

    Restaurant

    3311 Main St, Anderson, IN 46013

Magro’S Cincinnatus

Magro’s Cincinnatus is a welcoming spot in Cincinnatus, NY, offering hearty meals, friendly service, and a genuine small-town dining experience worth revisiting.

Follow Us

The information here is community-driven and not from an official source. If you are the site owner, we welcome you to contact us.